Editorial Guidelines & Research Method
Last Updated: October 2026 • Strict Separation of Commercial Relationships and Editorial Scoring
Gem Picked was founded to eradicate affiliate puffery, fake 5-star review aggregation, and superficial “Top 10” listicles. Every product we feature is researched before it is recommended: we study what long-term owners report in forums and communities, what independent reviewers and published teardowns found, and what the manufacturer specifies. We publish the trade-offs as plainly as the strengths, and every claim is checked against its source.
01. Four Inviolable Editorial Commandments
No manufacturer or retailer can purchase inclusion into our benchmark catalog. We do not accept sponsored reviews, gifted review units with editorial stipulations, or native placement fees.
No tool is universal. Every dossier must clearly identify who the product is NOT for (“Who Should Skip”) and document the engineering compromise inherent in its design.
Each highlight, trade-off, specification and comparison is checked against the source it came from: manufacturer documentation, independent reviews or owner reports. Claims we cannot verify are not published.
Where we compare several UK retailers, the main buy button goes to the lowest total price (item price plus UK delivery), regardless of commission rates.
02. The 4-Axis Scoring Rubric
Every product scored on Gem Picked receives an editorial rating between 0.0 and 10.0 on four axes, based on the research behind its dossier:
03. Verification Badges Explained
Tested by Us
Reserved for products we have physically handled and tested ourselves.
Researched and Fact-Checked
Researched from long-term owner reports, independent reviews and teardowns, and manufacturer specifications, with every claim checked against its source.
04. Corrections & Technical Inquiries
We aim for complete accuracy. If a specification changes because of a manufacturer revision, or you spot an error, we check it and correct it promptly.
Send corrections to our editor at hello@gempicked.co.uk.